In this work we provide an alternative view on the advanced economies tendencies to stagnation, based on josef steindls contributions. Facts, causes and cures edited by coen teulings and richard baldwin cepr press a a voxeu. Secular stagnation is defined as a situation when policy interest rates bounded at zero fail to stimulate demand sufficiently, due to low or negative neutral real interest rates and low inflation. How is this framework developed by and these themes launched by summers elaborated by the other contributors to voxeu s secular stagnation.
Six years after the crisis and the recovery is still anaemic despite years of zero interest rates. This ebook gathers the thinking of leading economists on whether secular stagnation to blame. Eprs secular stagnation and the euro area members research service page 5 of 8 this forms the basis of summers new secular stagnation hypothesis. To see how we can get secular stagnation in such a loanablefunds world, we introduce a shock, say, an ageing population a demographic imbalance, a rise in extreme inequality, or an asian savings glut, due to which the savings schedule shifts. This has spurred debates on the possibility of introducing negative interest rates in the monetary policy toolkit.
What mainstream economists get wrong about secular stagnation. Ben bernanke and larry summers are in a blog war over. Stagnation is gripping several of the worlds largest economies and many view this as secular, not transient. A lazy profession revives a phrase meant to whitewash its own policy failures. Aug 23, 2014 the voxeu ebook secular stagnation begins with a. In the model, an increase in inequality, a slowdown in population growth, and a tightening of borrowing limits all reduce. The economics of secular stagnation secular stagnation. The following figure, taken from a financial times blog post, shows the duration and average rate of growth of every economic expansion in the postwar period. Seven years after the financial crisis, global growth remains anaemic and the policy setting is nowhere near normal. Ben bernanke and larry summers are in a blog war over secular stagnation. The origin of secular stagnation vox, cepr policy portal voxeu. Research explores the origin of secular stagnation, looking at the impact of the great recession on expectations. Excessive, crossborder lending and borrowing among ez members in the precrisis years much of which ended up in nontraded sectors was why greeces deficit deceit. With donald trump voted in as the 45 th us president, the world economy has witnessed another sobering reminder of the rise of populism, inwardlooking politics and a sweeping antiestablishment wave, having barely recovered from the last with britains vote to leave the eu.
Larry summers has revived the notion of secular stagnation that goes back to. In the wake of the sharp recession of 1937, a debate over the causes of stagnation began to spread in the economics profession. All economists involved in it acknowledge that the growth environment since the financial crisis differs from what it was before. In a theory of accumulation and secular stagnation, aronoff explores malthus ideas relating to secular stagnation and uses the insight gained to understand the origins of the subpar growth and tepid employment, periodically punctuated by booms, that has plagued the us economy since the turn of the millennium.
If the private sectors savings are higher that its investment, then the sum of investment. One would expect to see that the world real interest rate, or that the real interest rates of those places where secular stagnation was a pressing problem, were chronically declining. February 5, 2020 october 12, 2017 by tejvan pettinger. None of them, however, get at the essence of the mattersince they specifically avoid the issue of contradictions in the accumulation process itself. How to tackle secular stagnation world economic forum. If secular stagnation was emerging, what would one expect to see. Following a decade of slow or sometimes negative growth after the great recessionin which annual growth per capita has been less than half the annual average since the 1970sthe institute for new economic thinking inet commissioned papers to explore the question of secular stagnation and offer solutions. Heres why larry summers is wrong about secular stagnation. Larry summers on secular stagnation vox, cepr policy portal. A new vox debate on secular stagnation vox, cepr policy. Excessive, crossborder lending and borrowing among ez members in the precrisis years much of which ended up.
Japans twodecadelong malaise and the great recession have renewed interest in the secular stagnation hypothesis, but until recently this theory has not been explicitly formalised. In economics, secular stagnation is a condition when there is negligible or no economic growth in a marketbased economy. Trade deficits and secular stagnation beat the press cepr. The debate on secular stagnation suffers from vagueness and several shortcomings, which affect its economic policy implications. My earlier post arguing that robotisation wouldnt destroy jobs, slash wages or drastically shorten the working week prompted many thoughtful responses. Secular stagnation in the eurozone vox, cepr policy portal.
The cepr press ebook on secular stagnation has been viewed over 80,000 times since it was published on 15 august 2014. Most observers expected the unusually deep recession to be followed by an unusually rapid recovery, but that hasnt happened. Apr 01, 2015 ben bernanke and larry summers are in a blog war over secular stagnation. The debate has shifted to what is now called secular stagnation, an expression coined by former us treasury secretary larry summers. Facts, causes and cures kindle edition by baldwin, richard, teulings, coen. Incorporated as a notforprofit foundation in 1971, and headquartered in geneva, switzerland, the forum is tied to no political, partisan or national interests. The term secular stagnation refers to a market economy with a chronic secular or longterm lack of demand. This ebook gathers the thinking of leading economists including larry summers, paul krugman. Fundamental changes are needed because the united states is suffering from an extended period of slow and declining growth, what is known as secular stagnation. In his remarks, summers gave his perspective on the profound macroeconomic challenge of the next 20 years in the industrial world. In this context, the term secular means longterm from latin saeculumcentury or lifetime, and is used in contrast to cyclical or shortterm. The term secular stagnation was originally coined by alvin hansen in 1938 to describe what he feared was the fate of the american economy following the great depression of the early 1930s. How secular stagnation spreads and how it can be cured vox.
Is the threat of secular stagnation in the eurozone real. With donald trump voted in as the 45 th us president, the world economy has witnessed another sobering reminder of the rise of populism, inwardlooking politics and a sweeping antiestablishment wave, having. Last month in this space i argued that we may be in a period of secular stagnation in which sluggish growth, output and employment at levels well below potential, and problematically low real interest rates might coincide for quite some time to come. Larry summers describes this as secular stagnation see summers. A model of secular stagnation vox, cepr policy portal. Richard serlin and others countered, arguing that if automation affects all sectors, then displaced workers may have nowhere to go. Secular stagnation a prolonged period in which satisfactory growth can only be achieved by unsustainable financial conditions may be the defining macroeconomic challenge of our times. Mar 31, 2015 ben bernanke looks at the question of whether the u. Leading economists from around the world are calling for swift policy action to mitigate the economic damage from the global pandemic. For this reason, i am quite certain that he is familiar with the concept of secular stagnation, which means a persistent shortfall in aggregate demand. In the aftermath of the global crisis, conventional monetary policy has been constrained by low interest rates in many major economies. Can secular stagnation morph into secular expansion. Ultimately, while secular stagnation is a powerful metaphor for our current malaise, we dont think its useful for investing. Business and management submitted by darkangel12 words 47021 pages 189.
Luckily, an expansionary fiscal policy can help overcome the problem and get growth back on. The latest voxeu ebook presents a consensus view of what caused the crisis and why. In an influential speech on november 8, 20 at the imf annual research conference, larry summers suggested that slow economic growth in the years following the 20072008 financial crisis might be. The world economic forum is an independent international organization committed to improving the state of the world by engaging business, political, academic and other leaders of society to shape global, regional and industry agendas. Teulings, c, and r baldwin 2014, secular stagnation. But as mentioned above, most of our authors view secular stagnation as a situation where low real interest rates, low inflation, and the zero lower. It is too early to tell whether secular stagnation is really secular, but if it is, current. The secular stagnation hypothesis has gained traction in the aftermath of the global crisis. How, and how far and fast, will the economic damage spread. The increase in life expectancy, which has not been offset by an increase in the retirement age, has led to an increase in the stocks of savings. This column by larry summers first published in the vox ebook secular stagnation. This paper should not be reported as representing the views of the european central bank ecb. The pdf remains freely downloadable, but as the european debate on secular stagnation is moving into policy circles, we decided to also make it a kindle book.
Demographics and the secular stagnation hypothesis in. Excessive, crossborder lending and borrowing among ez members in. The extraordinary events needed to pull the economy out of depression as well as the recent weakness suggest that it is worth considering secular stagnation. Posts about secular stagnation written by bankunderground. The key to understanding why lies in the concept of secular stagnation. Harvard university economist larry summers warned that the global economy was in danger of entering a period of secular stagnationa concept created in the 1930s to describe a period of low or nonexistent growth due to a glut of savings and diminished investing. The underselling is reflected in the fact that too little is invested compared to the amount of savings. In this second ebook on the coronavirus from cepr and vox, the experts are unanimous that the case for. Demographics and the secular stagnation hypothesis in europe. Facts, causes, and cures a new vox ebook 1 coen t eulings, richard baldwin seven years on since financial market turmoil signalled the start of the great recession, output.
The secular stagnation hypothesis suggests that low interest rates may be the new normal in years to come. Economists, such as larry summers have written on secular stagnation arguing the world has entered a period of substantially lower economic growth. This column argues that demography has played an important role in reducing the interest rates. Oct 12, 2017 secular stagnation is a term coined to describe a prolonged period of lower economic growth.
In most advanced economies, both real longterm interest rates and productivity growth have decreased since the early 1990s. In this second ebook on the coronavirus from cepr and vox, the experts are unanimous that the case for decisive and coordinated fiscal stimulus is overwhelming. Dec 21, 2017 the result is inadequate investment and a shortage of aggregate demand in the short run, which lead to longterm stagnation as long as the savingsinvestment imbalance persists. Demographics and the secular stagnation hypothesis in europe carlo favero, vincenzo galasso, sun, 10182015 demographic trends in europe do not support empirically the secular stagnation hypothesis. E31,e32,e52 abstract we propose an overlapping generations new keynesian model in which a permanent or very persistent. What to do about secular stagnation foreign affairs. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. This chapter explains the core logic of a new model that does just that. Ben bernanke and larry summers are in a blog war over secular. Each of the pillars of the mainstream idea of secular stagnation brings a hazy focus toward the contradictions of capitalism. Larry summers, for one, thinks that its part of a longerterm trend towards what he calls secular stagnation. It argues that this was a classic sudden stop crisis not a publicdebt crisis.
Before turning to policy, though, there are two central issues regarding the secular stagnation thesis that have to be addressed. Ben bernanke looks at the question of whether the u. This would have profound consequences for future growth and development in both wealthy and poorer countries. Fears of secular stagnation were common at the end of world war ii and were proved wrong. The views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the ecb.
The resurgence of interest in secular stagnation is greatly welcomed. Dec 16, 20 if secular stagnation concerns are relevant to our current economic situation, there are obviously profound policy implications that i will address in a subsequent column. If blinder accepted the problem of secular stagnation, then as a matter of accounting identities he would have to accept that a trade deficit makes the problem worse. Summers 2015 regards a chronic excess of saving over investment as the essence of secular stagnation. He points to factors, such as ineffective monetary policy and weak demand for. Sep 18, 2014 the debate has shifted to what is now called secular stagnation, an expression coined by former us treasury secretary larry summers. To find the source of the myth that is secular stagnation, economists need only look in the mirror. Secularstagnationcausesandconsequences ubs global topics. This ebook gathers the views of leading economists including summers, krugman, gordon, blanchard, koo, eichengreen, caballero, glaeser and a dozen others. Economic fluctuations and growth, monetary economics conditions of secular stagnation low interest rates, below target inflation, and sluggish output growth now characterize much of the global economy. Facts, causes, and cures that richard baldwin and myself with contributions of many of the leading macroeconomists in the world drew so much attention. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading secular stagnation.
The concept of secular stagnation originally formulated by the eminent depressionera economist alvin hansen, has experienced a revival since my. In a new report, beyond secular stagnation, morgan stanley s global investment committee deconstructs the consensus view by examining some of the most frequentlycited drivers of secular stagnation. In the last few years, it has become widely accepted that the global economy has been mired in a depressed condition that lawrence summers. How is this framework developed by and these themes launched by summers elaborated by the other contributors to voxeu. Economic fluctuations and growth, monetary economics. Jan 06, 2014 last month in this space i argued that we may be in a period of secular stagnation in which sluggish growth, output and employment at levels well below potential, and problematically low real interest rates might coincide for quite some time to come. The origin of secular stagnation world economic forum. Conditions of secular stagnation low interest rates, below target inflation, and sluggish output growth now characterize much of the global economy. Nowhere in the developed world is secular stagnation more visible than in the eurozone. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets.
Fukao kyoji hitotsubashi university and rieti ikeuchi kenta national institute of science and technology policy. Today, secular stagnation should be viewed as a contingency to. Some time ago speaking at the imf, i joined others who have invoked the old idea of secular stagnation and raised the possibility that the american and global economies could not rely on normal market mechanisms to assure full employment and strong growth without sustained unconventional policy support. Can you imagine a set of circumstances better calculated to impress upon a young economist the idea that the fundamental economic problem was not cyclical ups and downs but secular stagnation. Secular stagnation refers to a situation of chronic underselling of a countrys goods and services. Rather, in the words of investment manager james montier of the gmo llc, secular stagnation is a policy choice that we as citizens and policymakers can confidently attack, especially as. Some commentators have suggested that this reflects some kind of secular stagnation which set in before the crisis. One can debate whether the stagnation is secular or not, but shortlived it is certainly not. Indeed, what you see here is that for some long time.
982 1110 1424 818 727 197 387 926 1133 1402 1101 1498 686 266 121 1390 885 965 1 258 1490 839 132 1201 747 578 1311 1317 696 330 864 1242 939 774 315 1088 975 484 1012 730 1283 1208